Was It Our Fault? #642
08/28/2020 05:45:00 PM
Rabbi Irwin Huberman
Author | |
Date Added | |
Automatically create summary | |
Summary |
Was It Our Fault?
It is perhaps one of the blessings and the curses of Judaism that we as a people have tended to be our own worst critics.
Throughout history, we have asked ourselves, “Have we contributed in some way toward the pain, injustice or persecution that we have endured?”
This question emerges in this week’s Torah portion, Ki Tetzei, as we are reintroduced to the Israelites’ nastiest enemy — the nation of Amalek.
These were the scoundrels who attacked from the rear the elderly, the physically or cognitively challenged, and others who walked slower, as we departed Egypt.
Centuries later, our tradition tells us that Haman, the villain of Purim, was a descendant of Amalek.
This week’s Torah portion reminds us to blot out Amalek whenever see it. But our tradition asks, “Who exactly were the Amalekites?” And, perhaps more importantly, “Why did they hate the Jews?”
Unexpectedly, the Talmud answers: “It was Abraham, Isaac and Jacob’s fault.”
The story of Timna, a non-Jewish princess, makes this clear. Timna asked to convert to Judaism, approaching Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, at various times. But, the Talmud says, “They did not accept her.”
So, Timna did something remarkable. She gave up her rights as a princess, and became the sex object — the concubine to Eliphaz, Jacob’s gruff nephew. Tradition quotes her as saying, “I had rather be a servant to the people Israel…than a Queen of another nation.”
When her son, Amalek, realizes the disgrace that his mother was subjected to, he and his descendants become Israel’s mortal enemy.
“Why,” asks the Talmud? “Because Abraham, Isaac and Jacob should not have rejected her.”
Amalek lesson #1: Judaism should be open to all. Those who wish to join should be encouraged and not rejected. Indeed, Judaism is less of a faith and more of a system of behavior.
We are here to help God repair an imperfect world, and those who wish to be part of this sacred mission — and adopt our laws, values and traditions — should be welcomed.
In recent years, rabbis have added a new layer to the seemingly straightforward story. They ask, “What were our most vulnerable doing at the back of the people in the first place? Shouldn’t they have been walking amongst the people, within their families — cared for and supported?”
Society has come a long way since biblical times, where those who were seen as flawed or imperfect were left behind. Each person has a unique mission to fulfill on this earth. Every one of us faces a challenge — some more visible than others.
Amalek lesson #2: All life is valued. Each of us has something to contribute. No one in society should be left behind, for we are only as strong as our most vulnerable link.
A thousand years ago, our greatest commentator, Rashi (1040-1105), noted that prior to God’s instructions concerning Amalek, the Israelites are told in the Bible to keep honest weights. The Torah has no tolerance for dishonesty in business.
What’s the connection?
Rashi says that when we cheat in business or elsewhere, we show a lack of faith in God that things will turn out as they are meant to.
Hence, when we are dishonest, we exhibit a lack of faith — a sign of vulnerability — and that opens the door for Amalek to attack.
Amalek lesson # 3: Honesty is directly linked to faith. Sometimes a negative incident may resolve many years later. The pain we endure today may serve as a foundation for something better.
The second century Sage, Nachum Ish Gamzu, said, "Gam zu l'tovah." In English this means: "This is also for good." In other words, “Trust in God.” Trust in the future.
Finally, with Rosh Hashanah less than three weeks away, it is perhaps appropriate that we begin searching within ourselves for the “Amalek” that we’ve accumulated during the past year.
Who are we angry at? What grudges are we holding? Who are we not speaking to? Where is that leading us?
Amalek lesson #4: No one is immune from attacking those who are sometimes unable to correct their own behavior. How many times have we uttered words that have hurt those we love in places which we know hurt the most? Indeed, there is a bit of Amalek in each of us.
Is it therefore possible — somewhere within these four lessons — to draw insights and to self-improve?
History has taught us that there will always be enemies, who will attack us at our weakest point — from generation to generation. Is there a way to strengthen our souls and reverse our negative destiny?
We are told in the Talmud that there are “Seventy faces of the Torah.” Each of us possesses the ability to learn and grow from a different facet.
By interacting with others — even those we disagree with — we become more whole.
As distasteful as the behavior of Amalek may have been, this week’s Torah portion — by encouraging us to examine our personal and communal behavior — can inspire us to be more welcoming, more honest, more compassionate and more kind.
When we combine these lessons, we help ensure that we will never let Amalek destroy us.
For Amalek can attack from many directions, from the borders of our people, to the strings of our hearts.
Shabbat Shalom, v’kol tuv.
Rabbi Irwin Huberman
..............................
Please join us on Zoom or Facebook,
Friday - 7:00 pm ET
for candle lighting, followed
by live Kabbalat Shabbat services:
Click link below to view or download
the abridged Friday Shabbat siddur: https://bit.ly/2JjvlL3
or: https://www.facebook.com/
..............................
Saturday Shabbat & Musaf Service:
10:00 am ET
Sim Shalom Shabbat & Musaf Siddur: https://bit.ly/2zMtxJ3
You can also dial into these services:
646-558-8656 (New York)
Meeting ID: 202 374 932
Find your local number: https://zoom.us/u/abImNXlmlW
Mon, October 13 2025
21 Tishrei 5786
Update this content.
Update this content.
Update this content.
Rabbi's Last 50 E-Sermons
The Rhythm of the Falling Rain # 892
Friday, Oct 3 6:00pmA Time to Return # 891
Friday, Sep 26 6:00pmThe Torah's Punchline # 890
Friday, Sep 19 5:00pmGOd's Plan - In its Time # 889
Friday, Sep 12 5:00pmForbidding Sexual Assault # 888
Friday, Sep 5 6:00pmJustice: God Mentioned it Twice #887
Friday, Aug 29 5:00pmWhat We Chose to See #886
Friday, Aug 22 5:00pmmORE THAN bREAD #885
Friday, Aug 15 5:00pmMosES AND THE pOWER OF wORDS #884
Friday, Aug 1 5:00pmAnother Birthday: The LIves WIthin our LIves #883
Friday, Jul 25 2:11pmGod and Women's Rights # 882
Friday, Jul 18 6:00pmJewish Respect for Privacy # 881
Friday, Jul 11 5:00pmThe Miser of Krakow #880
Friday, Jul 4 5:00pmKorach -- The Critic with No Answers #879
Friday, Jun 27 5:00pmEmbracing our "Weirdness" #878
Friday, Jun 20 6:00pmIsrael and Iran - No Time for "Karet" #877
Friday, Jun 13 5:00pmEvery Job is Blessed, Man #876
Friday, Jun 6 5:00pmWhich Tribe Are You? #875
Friday, May 30 5:00pmRe-balancing the rich and poor #874
Friday, May 23 5:00pmTevye: The World Changes, and We With It #873
Friday, May 16 5:00pmThe Food We Waste #872
Friday, May 9 5:00pmDoes Prayer Heal the Sick? #871
Friday, May 2 5:00pmPesach: Things I Love and Hate #870
Friday, Apr 18 5:00pmChametz of the Soul and "the Potato" #869
Friday, Apr 11 5:00pmGod is in the Drudgery #868
Friday, Apr 4 5:05pmJews and HOrns - How Did it Begin? #867
Friday, Mar 14 5:00pmAttack on the Elderly and Disabled #866
Friday, Mar 7 5:00pmBowling Alone #865
Friday, Feb 28 5:00pmHope in a Divided World #864
Friday, Feb 21 5:00pmFrom Whom Did You Learn "Your" Torah? #863
Thursday, Feb 13 10:00amThe Voice of Women #862
Friday, Feb 7 5:00pmNowhere Without our Children and Elders #861
Friday, Jan 31 5:00pmReclaiming our Voice #860
Friday, Jan 24 5:00pmWhat's in Your Hebrew Name? #859
Friday, Jan 17 5:00amVisiting the Sick: Is There a Right Time? #858
Friday, Jan 10 5:00pmDads and their Imperfect Journeys #857
Friday, Jan 3 5:00pmWhat Does "Israel" Really Mean? #856
Friday, Dec 13 5:01pmRunning From OUr Problems #855
Friday, Dec 6 3:00pmThe "R-Rated Torah"#853
Friday, Nov 22 11:39amLeaving God Behind #852
Friday, Nov 15 5:00pmYour Name Means Something #851
Friday, Nov 8 5:00pmDemocracy as a Jewish Practice #850
Friday, Nov 1 5:00pmThe Rabbi and the "Ugly" Man #849
Friday, Oct 25 5:00pmsUKKOT AND THE tENEMENTS #848
Friday, Oct 18 5:00pm"Wedding After the Funeral" #847
Friday, Sep 27 5:37pm"The King is in the Field" #846
Friday, Sep 13 5:00pmJudging Others Too Quickly #845
Friday, Sep 6 5:00pmIs Life a Blessing or a Curse? #844
Friday, Aug 30 5:00pmWhat is in Your Heart? #843
Friday, Aug 23 5:01pmLearning Judaism's 11th Commandment #842
Friday, Aug 16 5:00pmUpdate this content.
CONGREGATION TIFERETH ISRAEL
40 Hill Street & Landing Road
Glen Cove, NY 11542
OFFICE@CTIONLINE.ORG | (516) 676-5080 | Fax: (516) 759-1905
Privacy Settings | Privacy Policy | Member Terms
©2025 All rights reserved. Find out more about ShulCloud